Man charged in Bay Shore murder arraigned on new charges

Nieves Reyes is accused of chasing Eugene Allen, 66, with a machete and then shooting and killing him on New York Avenue in Bay Shore last week.

News 12 Staff

•

Aug 1, 2025, 12:52 PM

•

Updated 20 hr ago

Share:

More Stories

0:20

Police: Swastikas, racial slur found etched into Wantagh playground

3h ago

0:39

Police: Westhampton Beach woman stole from Quogue shop, got into fight with its owner

11h ago

1:19

Vandalism spree damages at least 10 vehicles in Deer Park, Dix Hills, Wheatley Heights

11h ago

0:22

Prosecutors: State parole officer from Freeport admitted possessing child sexual abuse material

yesterday

0:24

Police: Westhampton Beach woman stole from Quogue shop, got into fight with its owner

11h ago

1:19

Vandalism spree damages at least 10 vehicles in Deer Park, Dix Hills, Wheatley Heights

11h ago

0:22

Prosecutors: State parole officer from Freeport admitted possessing child sexual abuse material

yesterday

0:24

Person wanted in connection to emaciated dog found in Suffolk that died

yesterday

0:15

Bayville man arrested for attempted burglary

2ds ago

The man accused of killing another man and shooting a Suffolk police officer has been indicted on a new charge.

Nieves Reyes is facing a new weapons charge as well as murder and three counts of attempted murder of a police officer.

Reyes is accused of chasing Eugene Allen, 66, with a machete and then shooting and killing him on New York Avenue in Bay Shore last week.

During the investigation, authorities say Reyes shot a Suffolk police officer in the face and opened fire on several others.

“What we have here is a malicious, ruthless and savage attack that occurred for absolutely no good reason at all,” said Suffolk DA Ray Tierney.

News 12 has been told the officer who was shot is recovering and doing well.

More from News 12

2:15